Home gym vs gym membership: what does each workout cost you?
Pick a smart gym or a rower, set your gym fee and how often you train: the calculator gives the cost of each workout, the month the machine pays for itself, and every machine that beats your gym.
We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. Learn more
Pick a machine, keep or drop its subscription, and set your own gym fee. The result is the cost of each workout over the years you keep the machine, the month its up-front cost is covered by the gym fees you no longer pay, and the list of machines that cost less per workout than your gym.
Default: $61, U.S. average expected for 2026 (HFA, Dec 2025)
The result appears here.
How is the cost per workout worked out?
- Up front = machine price + accessories the brand says you need + delivery or installation, when the store publishes its price. Tonal 2: $3,295 + $495 Essential Accessories Bundle + $295 installation = $4,085 [calc].
- Subscription = monthly price x the months counted. In the default mode every plan is kept for the whole period; switch to "only what the brand requires" to count Tonal's 12-month commitment and nothing for optional plans.
- Per workout = (up front + subscription) / (workouts a week x 52 x years).
- Break-even = the first month when the gym fees you would have paid are larger than what you have paid for the machine and its plan so far.
Worked example, 5 years, 3 workouts a week, plans kept, gym at $61: the Speediance Gym Monster 2 costs $2,579 + 60 x $19.99 = $3,778.40, or $4.84 a workout, against $4.69 at the gym. Drop the optional Wellness Plus plan and it falls to $3.31, with break-even in month 43 [calc]. The gap between those two lines is the whole question of which smart gyms work without a subscription.
Which prices does the calculator use?
| Speediance Gym Monster 2 (Basic) | Tonal 2 | Bowflex Xtreme 2 SE Home Gym | Ergatta Lite Rower | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price (Nov 14, 2026) | $2,579 | $3,295 | $1,499 | $1,399 |
| Subscription | optional ($19.99/mo) | $59.95/mo required, 12 months min. | none | optional ($39/mo) |
| Required accessories | none | $495 | none | none |
| Delivery or install | Doorstep delivery by truck; white-glove service $150 to $210 extra (optional). | "Installation starts at $295, calculated at checkout." Wall-mounted by Tonal's installers. | FedEx Parcel $199; White Glove $399. | Free shipping ($150 value) with self-assembly. |
| Max load or resistance | 220 lb total, 110 lb per arm (2S: 130 lb per arm) | 250 lb digital weight, 1 lb steps | 210 lb Power Rod, upgradable to 410 lb | Water resistance |
| Size in use | 48.03 x 27.16 x 72.83 in | 21.5 x 5.5 x 50.9 in | 76 x 78 x 83.25 in | 82 x 23 x 38 in |
| Stored or folded | 14.56 x 27.16 x 72.83 in | not published | not published | 23 x 21 x 82 in |
| Ceiling | not published | 7 ft 10 in ideal, 7 ft minimum | not published | not published |
| Machine weight | 171.96 lb | not published | 174 lb | 72 lb |
| Max user weight | not published | not published | 300 lb | 320 lb |
| Warranty | 2 years (main unit) | 2-year limited warranty | 7 years machine, 5 years Power Rods | 5 years |
| Official store | Speediance store | Tonal store | Bowflex store | Ergatta store |
Bowflex prices are the list prices: the sale that showed $899 and $2,199 ended at 11:59 pm Central on November 14, 2026. Speediance, Ergatta and Echelon show compare-at prices on their stores; we keep the price you pay. Every machine, with its photo and size, is in the full comparison.
What the calculator leaves out
- Sales tax, financing interest and any resale value at the end.
- Extra accessories you choose (benches, mats, bars). Add them in the accessories box.
- Electricity: a digital-weight machine draws power, a water rower does not. No brand in our list publishes a figure per workout.
- What a gym gives that a machine does not: free weights, classes, a pool. And what a machine gives: no commute. Neither has a dollar value here.
Before you order, check that the machine fits: the space and ceiling check uses each brand's published sizes.
Frequently asked questions
Is a home gym cheaper than a gym membership?
It depends on the subscription more than on the price tag. Over 5 years at 3 workouts a week, a gym at $61 a month costs $4.69 a workout [calc]. A Bowflex Xtreme 2 SE ($1,499 plus $199 shipping, no subscription) comes to $2.18 a workout; a Tonal 2 with its membership kept for the 5 years comes to $9.85 [calc, prices of Nov 14, 2026].
Where does the $61 gym fee come from?
It is the average monthly health and fitness spending that Americans planning a fitness goal expected for 2026, from a Health & Fitness Association survey run by Kantar (2,000 adults, December 5 to 16, 2025, published December 29, 2025). Replace it with your own gym's fee: that is the number that matters.
What does "required subscriptions only" count?
Only the months a brand makes you pay: Tonal's 12-month membership commitment, and one month for Echelon, whose plan is picked at checkout and can be cancelled. Optional plans (Speediance Wellness Plus, Ergatta) count as zero in that mode.
Does the calculator include sales tax?
No. Prices are the ones shown on the official U.S. stores on November 14, 2026, before tax. Delivery or installation is added only when the store publishes a price for it.